Sybil Wa doesn’t think so.
That’s what the mother of three, who lives near Yonge St. and The Esplanade, said following Deputy Mayor Doug Holyday’s comments that downtown isn’t a suitable place to live with children.
Holyday, a former Etobicoke mayor who lives doors down from his grandchildren on a “very quiet” suburban street, made the remarks as he argued against forcing a condo developer to include family-friendly three-bedroom units in a proposed 47-storey building at King St. W. and John St.
“Where will these children play — on King St.?” Holyday asked.
But Wa, who lives in a condo with her husband, Adam Parkin, and children, who are 10, 6 and 2, said raising kids downtown is safe and convenient.
“I see mostly benefits, which is why I’m here,” she said, standing in the shade of a park near Spadina Ave. and Adelaide St.
Wa is part of a generation of young families choosing to live downtown and take advantage of its amenities. Some 40 other families are doing the same in her building alone.
Their reasons vary from sustainability to accessibility of cultural activities, but Wa said they all want many of the same things: improved city policies that take into account the growing population of families like themselves. She called Holyday’s comments provocative.
To jeers from other councillors, Holyday said: “As far as raising your children downtown, maybe some people wish to do that. I think most people wouldn’t.
“I mean, I could just see now: ‘Where’s little Ginny?’ ‘Well, she’s downstairs playing in the traffic on her way to the park.’ ”
The city’s acting chief planner, Gregg Lintern, told Holyday the area in question is “a neighbourhood, an emerging neighbourhood.”
Having families live downtown “just makes for a healthier city,” Lintern added.
But Holyday, dubious, said: “It makes for a healthier city to have children out on a street like King St. where it’s bumper-to-bumper traffic and people galore at all times of night and day? I just think of raising my own family there. That’s not the place I’d choose.”
Josh Matlow, a midtown councillor, began his subsequent speech as follows: “To Councillor Holyday: Are you — are you serious? Do you really believe that there is some danger to children by living in the downtown area?”
Holyday, whose proposal to eliminate the 10 per cent requirement was defeated 27-4, was unrepentant in later comments to reporters. “There are healthier places to raise children,” he said.
The debate was the latest example of the stark divide between the right-leaning suburban councillors who populate Mayor Rob Ford’s administration and the left-leaning downtown councillors who serve as the de facto opposition.
In December, Councillor Adam Vaughan derided Councillor Doug Ford’s Etobicoke ward as “an industrial park.”
Maxime Béland, who strolled along the lakefront to the beach Thursday with son Xavier, 5, moved from Montreal to a condo at Queens Quay and Yonge St. about two years ago.
“We wanted to try the condo life. We’ve never been very good at cutting the grass or shovelling the snow,” he said.
Xavier plays soccer at Cherry Beach every week. But his dad cautions him against bouncing a ball near their lakefront condo to prevent it rolling in the street.
“Regardless of where you live, you adapt. Raising a child is the same. Obviously it’s busy,” said Béland. “But you go a block that way,” he said pointing east, “and there’s nothing.”
The family enjoys great pizza, street festivals, a ROM membership, swimming in the condo pool and playing at the gym.
“We can cross the street, jump in the ferry and be on the island in 30 minutes,” said Béland.
Kids should be able to grow up and live their full life in the city, said Wa, adding that families are setting roots downtown.
“There are a growing number of children in the downtown core who are thriving, not playing in traffic as the councillor suggests,” she said. “There’s no reason why they should have to move away because there aren’t the schools or there aren’t the open spaces or amenities.”
Wa has out-of-town friends who come in for special events, but rarely go to the free night at the art gallery because it isn’t walking distance from home. “I mean, my kids have participated in Nuit Blanche since they were (young) because it’s so easy,” she said.
City policies and planning have yet to catch up with this lifestyle, Wa said.
“The city is less accessible to children than it should be.”
Original Article
Source: the star
Author: Chantaie Allick and Daniel Dale
No comments:
Post a Comment